Ice Cube Trays

The Best 12 Ice Cube Trays To Buy In 2021

It is possible that when preparing a cocktail or glass of ice water, the last thing on your mind is the ice, but experts have revealed that choosing the right size and shape of cubes can make your drink taste better and keep it colder for longer periods of time.

Even though many ice cube pans freeze water, they have multiple disadvantages including awkward handling, hard to release ice when full, taking up too much space in the freezer, or producing mistakenly shaped cubes. In order to eliminate these problems, silicone molds and trays with locking lids have been introduced as an alternative to classic plastic trays. Stainless steel, silicone, and plastic are all common forms of these materials.

Types of Ice Cube Trays

  • Plastic Ice Trays – Cheaper and easier to wash, this is one of the cheapest. Additionally, they are lightweight, but the possibility of absorbing weird freezer odors rises due to the uncovered ice cubes.
  • Metal Ice Cube Tray – The metal ice cube trays that are the most expensive and heavier are usually made up of stainless steel. BPA is not present in these products, which is a significant advantage over some plastics.
  • Built-in Ice Trays – Inside the freezer section you will find these. Alternatively, remove the tray holding the ice cubes so you can scoop the ice. External ones can also be accessed through the front door of the refrigerator.
  • Silicone Tray – Silicone made from rubber is used in the manufacturing of this tray. The cubes are very easy to remove from these since they’re so flexible. It’s unfortunate that odors tend to accumulate in silicone ice cube trays.
  • Standard Ice Tray (removable lid) – There is a plastic lid on these trays. The spillage that occurs when an uncovered tray is placed in an icebox ensues. The ice cubes produced using these trays usually absorb freezer odors, leaving them with a flat taste. The unpalatable cubes will also affect the flavor of what you plan to eat with them.
  • Small Ice Cube Tray – Cubes of this size can be made with these trays. The convenient size makes them excellent for times when you don’t want ice chips, but still don’t want a conventional cube. They are ideal for storing small quantities of food in the freezer, such as when preserving herbs.

Things To Consider Before Buying Ice Trays

  • Material Used – The market is filled with stainless steel ice trays as well as plastic ice trays. The stainless steel material does not absorb freezer odors, which is why some prefer it over plastic. Yet these machines tend to be difficult to operate, which makes it difficult for ice cubes to be released. In the case of plastic ice trays, silicone materials are usually used that are highly durable and can bend easily, making cubing easier.
  • Ice Shapes and Sizes – The traditional cube molds usually make rectangles and squares of one centimeter or larger. However, there are molds that make circles and squares of one centimeter and bigger. It is faster for a larger cube to melt in your drink, so larger cubes are preferable for drinks where you don’t want diluted alcohol in your drink.
  • Count of Cubes – The size of ice trays depends on the number of cubes they can make in one sitting. They typically create four to 18 cubes at a time. The best tray to get is one with a high mold count so that it will be able to keep up as you entertain. You may need a tray with fewer rows if you do not have a cup holder.
  • Compatibility – Choosing an ice tray that is right for your freezer is essential. In case you have a small freezer on your hands, choose ice cube trays with lids that offer a slim profile. For those with a lot of meal prep containers and frozen veggie bags in their freezers, you can use ice cube trays with lids. The covered design makes it easy to stack them on top of each other – or to stack them around your frozen items – without spilling or causing a mess.

Here’s a look at the types of ice trays we’ve compiled to suit your liking. Check out the best of the best.

1/12:

OMORC Ice Cube Trays

The compact trays can be stacked so that they do not take up too much space, and their thermoplastic elastomer molds make cubes easy to remove. It's just a matter of gently pressing the button and your cube will pop out effortlessly without any cracking, twisting, or bending on your part.

Price

$9.99

Pros
  • Easy to remove ice
  • Easy to fill
  • Saves freezer space
Cons
  • Limited number of ice
2/12:

Tovolo Cube Ice Mold Trays

Its food-grade silicone construction lets it bend in any direction so multiple cubes can be released at once, without affecting the taste of your ice cubes. And unlike similar plastic molds, it won't crack or warp in the freezer, unlike similar plastic molds.

Price

$13.25

Pros
  • Color variants
  • Affordable
Cons
  • No lid attached
3/12:

W&P Peak Silicone Ice Tray

The silicone-wrapped stainless steel interior of this 12-cube tray ensures spill prevention and ensures that the lid is securely fastened as well as the benefits of flexibility and rigidity.

Price

$13.76

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Comes with lid
Cons
  • Difficult to remove ice
4/12:

Ecozoi Stainless Steel Metal Ice Cube Tray

This metal model is a vintage ice tray remnant that provides a more eco-friendly design and comes stocked with 18 pockets for ice cubes.

Price

$29.95

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • BPA free
  • Elegant design
Cons
  • Quite expensive
  • Hard to remove ice
5/12:

OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

This OXO Good Grips No-Spill plastic tray comes with a sealed silicone lid, so you can stack and transport it without spilling anything. By using the lid instead of a bag, your cubes will stay fresh longer while absorbing an unpleasant freezer smell. The lid can be removed to use your dishwasher's top rack.

Price

$9.99

Pros
  • Easy to fill
  • Comes with attached lid
Cons
  • Difficult to remove lid
6/12:

Arrow Home 60 Cube Ice Tray

With this tray, you get 60 tiny ice balls because it comes in a set of three. Kids can enjoy playing with them in a cup of juice, or adults can toss them into their favorite cocktail.

Price

$8.65

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Durable tray
Cons
  • Difficult to stack trays
  • No lid included
7/12:

Adoric Ice Cube Trays

This tray is designed for ice balls, one will create two-inch cubes, the other two-inch cubes. Having large cubes on hand while drinking a strong drink you don't want to dilute too quickly works for both.

Price

$12.98

Pros
  • Durable material
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Hard to use sphere mold
8/12:

LeeYean Silicone Mini Ice Cube Trays

Due to its construction, it freezes at the same speed as its larger counterparts. It is made from silicone, which flexes in any direction to make it easy to release. It is dishwasher safe to make cleanup a breeze.

Price

$7.98

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Ice is easy to remove
Cons
  • Small size of ice
9/12:

Samuelworld Ice Cube Tray

This dishwasher-safe, food-grade silicone ice tray makes eight two-inch square cubes at once and comes with a stackable, odor-resistant, and slip-resistant lid to stack in even the smallest freezer if space is at a premium. In addition to its bendable molds, it also makes removing the cubes easy.

Price

$12

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Big size of ice
Cons
  • Limited count of ice produced
10/12:

Kitch Easy Release White Ice Cube Tray

These trays can be stacked up in the freezer, line up neatly without sticking to one another. When one twists off the cubes, the cubes free themselves with no smell, no residue, no concern for BPA, and no off-taste from other foods at all.

Price

$10.95

Pros
  • BPA free plastic
  • Affordable
  • Right count and size of ice produced
Cons
  • Not dishwasher friendly
  • No lid attached
11/12:

Glacio Ice Cube Trays

These black silicone ice trays from Glacio are suitable for freezing fruit juice, soup, or even baby food because they're BPA-free. In addition, the trays are easy to clean off quickly and can go in the dishwasher.

Price

$10.95

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Limited count of ice produced
12/12:

Vremi Large Silicone Ice Cube Trays

With this set, you receive two large silicone ice cube trays containing 8 large ice cubes each. Perfect size for mixing whiskey, tequila, or even cocktails in general, each cube measures 1.75".

Price

$14.47

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Durable material
Cons
  • Limited count of ice produced

Related Questions & Answers About Ice Cube Trays

It usually takes three to four hours to freeze the standard ice tray (plastic models with 12 tapered cubes).
Yes, but with a great amount of caution. Get stainless steel if you opted to buy one that is made with metal. Be sure to search for the "BPA-free" sticker if you choose plastic trays.
Ice cube trays are designed to be filled with water, placed in a freezer to freeze eventually into ice.
You can wash the trays with a couple of spritzes of dish soap soaked in warm water.
Because certain plastics have been discovered to be incredibly toxic, ice cube trays made of plastic can actually be dangerous. If you put frozen food into them over an extended period of time, the toxicity may seep into the food.
Yes. Milk can be poured into an ice cube tray and frozen. Please be sure to leave enough space at the top of the container when you pour it so that when it freezes, the contents will expand.
Let the bottom of the ice tray stand under warm water for a few seconds. Next, flip the tray right-side up and twist the ends in opposite directions - one toward you and one away from you.